hi sk forum, for those of you who have been watching SC matches on gomtv you might have noticed that they show stats of the players, mapcontroll, micro, macro, strategy and so on, they said it was decided by the community that got to vote on what they thought the players should have and it seems it turned out pretty well, i think sk should make a huge poll on their main page where we can vote on stuff like this, would be pretty awesome :)

example

moon

micro 10/10
macro 10/10
mapcontroll 10/10
consitancy 7/10
and many more stat things etc!

Jubei

micro 0/10
macro 0/10
mapcontrol 10/10
consistancy 15%/100%

Grubby

Micro 8/10
Macro 10/10
Mapcontrol 10/10
Consistancy what do u mean by that?

as in how long he manages to keep up his good results. For example Sky has a good consistency, although he doesn't always win he always gets to top 3. Grubby has had bad consistency this year, sometimes he gets top 3 and after that he just loses in the first group stage for the next 5 tournaments.

aah ok, so Grubby is 6/10 imo.

Lyn

micro 10/10
macro 10/10
mapcontrol 10/10
consistancy 10/10

fov

micro 10/10
macro 10/10
mapcontrol 10/10
race 2/10

Agreeeeed.

i would rather have something like TLPD http://www.teamliquid.net/tlpd/

It's a nice idea, but it would get abused sooooooooo much, just like the player nicknames feature. Fanboys rating everything 10, haters rating everything 0. Sad but true.

this kind of thing worked for the sc community and it would be nice to have one for wc3, only problem is who would bother making it, well i think sk would simply LOVE to be the ones who made this !

i need everyone to spam sk admins and have them make a huge poll with top 100 players or something and we can vote on each and everyone of them in each stat thing, and it should have way more stat category's then the few i posted. that was just to show how the end result could look like after a few people had cast their vote on a player's stats.

the poker community got the same thing where they rank the pros in everything, but that's more serious than this will ever get i suppose :P

I'd like to rank my big idol and countryman(?), the wicked soul of simplistic gaming and the emperor of potm, Knutzi.
micro 100/10
macro 1/10
mapcontrol 10/10
consistancy 1/10
potmcontrol over 9000/10

mTwAMD.Check

Micro 10/10
Macro 9/10
Mapcontrol 10/10
race 11/10

Happy

Micro 9/10
Macro 2/10
Mapcontrol 9/10
consitancy 9/10

Reign

Micro 9/10
Macro 10/10
Mapcontrol 7/10
Potential 11/10
Race -10/10

"timing" (or "decision making" in other words) is a very important skill, while "map control" is somehow related to macro

ANGRY_KOREA_MAN

Micro 4/10
Macro 10/10 (beautiful)
Mapcontrol 10/10
Countering units 10/10
Style 10/10
Chat 1000/10

imo a simple rang system would be prettier than point system. F would be worsts obviously A secondbest, then S superior with additional + and -

You people need to stop simplifying things and see the whole picture for how skilled a player REALLY is.

Sky

micro 9/10
macro 10/10
mapcontroll 10/10
consitancy 9/10
love to game - 8

Deadman

micro 8/10
macro 9/10
mapcontroll 9/10
consitancy 7/10
love to game - 1

FaTC

Micro 10/10
Macro 9/10
ConsistEncy 8/10
Important matches 5/10
Practise/Dedication 4/10

WE.Pepsi.Sky

micro 9/10
macro 9/10
mapcontroll 10/10
consitancy 7/10

Xyligan

micro 7/10
macro 9/10
mapcontroll 10/10
consitancy 9/10
love to game - 7

Happy

micro 8/10
macro 8/10
mapcontroll 9/10
consitancy 9/10
love to game - 8