NEWS
MLG Columbus: flawed but fascinating
MLG Columbus has come and gone, leaving a slightly bitter taste in the mouth. At least the games were fantastic.
By Michael 'Zechs' Radford
Jun 7, 2010 14:38
MLG Columbus has come and gone, leaving a slightly bitter taste in the mouth. At least the games were fantastic.Before I talk about any of the WoW played at MLG this weekend, I want to discuss the tournament and the coverage. GotForums has been the official partner of MLG for a few years now and has never really set the world alight with its coverage but at least in the past they had the bare minimum. But this weekend, results were hours late – so much so that I came home from a barbecue at 2am on Sunday morning and found that the results I had from Friday and Saturday were barely behind what GF had in their system, despite six or so hours more games having been played.
Now, when you’re working alone from home with no official help you might be forgiven for being a little bit behind. But with a team of ON-SITE staff, it’s just unforgivable. I suppose I should have seen the warning signs with the pleas for volunteer writers before the event but you live in hope, I suppose.
On the bright side… the tournament itself showcased some of the best WoW matches in the game’s history. The grand final would have been a fine spectacle for any event, and was the closest MLG final that I remember. I’ve never been a fan of MLG’s bizarre tournament formats but Complexity Red made it work yesterday. Well, almost. Without the 3-1 lead from the first game, things might have been even closer than the uber-tense 6-4 finale we got.
But what really hit home for me, was the fact that RMP is still around. Like some kind of rash, it just refuses to go away. It fades for a while, so much that you think it’s gone entirely. And just when you stop looking for it altogether; bam! It’s right back where it was before, irritating your gen… erm… winning tournaments.
But in fact, it never did quite die-off at all. MLG wasn’t a resurrection but more of a return to form. Just because a rogue/lock/shaman team won IEM; just because Wizardcleave has been the talk of the TR, everyone forgot about the classic comp. But if we look at closer at IEM, RMP did just fine. Two teams out of the top four were RMP and only a sub-par performance from Hydra and co, combined with an above-par one from EG stopped it being absolutely on top.
Still, an RMP mirror in a finals match is something a bit rarer. You have to look all the way back to IEM Cologne to see Ensidia vs aAa, in fact. Fittingly, Ensidia – or Dignitas as they are now – is the only other team to still regularly play RMP at a high level. It just goes to show that through all the flavour-of-the-month comps and the trinket-based cheese, sometimes sticking to your guns works just as well.
There is one last thing I’d like to pick up on the RMP subject, though. Was Complexity’s RMP some kind of American secret weapon? Even the commentators seemed genuinely surprised to see it. Forget about the Spanish Inquisition, nobody expects the American RMP!
The Zechs Files will return next week but you can follow me on Twitter for regular updates on all things esports.
Now, when you’re working alone from home with no official help you might be forgiven for being a little bit behind. But with a team of ON-SITE staff, it’s just unforgivable. I suppose I should have seen the warning signs with the pleas for volunteer writers before the event but you live in hope, I suppose.
"The tournament itself showcased some of the best WoW matches in the game’s history."
On the bright side… the tournament itself showcased some of the best WoW matches in the game’s history. The grand final would have been a fine spectacle for any event, and was the closest MLG final that I remember. I’ve never been a fan of MLG’s bizarre tournament formats but Complexity Red made it work yesterday. Well, almost. Without the 3-1 lead from the first game, things might have been even closer than the uber-tense 6-4 finale we got.
But what really hit home for me, was the fact that RMP is still around. Like some kind of rash, it just refuses to go away. It fades for a while, so much that you think it’s gone entirely. And just when you stop looking for it altogether; bam! It’s right back where it was before, irritating your gen… erm… winning tournaments.
But in fact, it never did quite die-off at all. MLG wasn’t a resurrection but more of a return to form. Just because a rogue/lock/shaman team won IEM; just because Wizardcleave has been the talk of the TR, everyone forgot about the classic comp. But if we look at closer at IEM, RMP did just fine. Two teams out of the top four were RMP and only a sub-par performance from Hydra and co, combined with an above-par one from EG stopped it being absolutely on top.
"an RMP mirror in a finals match is something a bit rarer. You have to look all the way back to IEM Cologne"
Still, an RMP mirror in a finals match is something a bit rarer. You have to look all the way back to IEM Cologne to see Ensidia vs aAa, in fact. Fittingly, Ensidia – or Dignitas as they are now – is the only other team to still regularly play RMP at a high level. It just goes to show that through all the flavour-of-the-month comps and the trinket-based cheese, sometimes sticking to your guns works just as well.
There is one last thing I’d like to pick up on the RMP subject, though. Was Complexity’s RMP some kind of American secret weapon? Even the commentators seemed genuinely surprised to see it. Forget about the Spanish Inquisition, nobody expects the American RMP!
The Zechs Files will return next week but you can follow me on Twitter for regular updates on all things esports.
RELATED NEWS
39 comments
Loading comments...
Most read last month
Most discussed last month


The fact is that results are default setting; the absolute bare minimum. Here i would say that i expect a lot more, especially from the OFFICIAL coverage site, but this is GotForums we're talking about. Pretty much any expectation is too high nowadays.
In fact, rather than arguing over opinions I can provide some direct evidence of how well the coverage was received: http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=25170441423&sid=1, http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=25170782253&sid=1, http://www.arenajunkies.com/showthread.php?t=183247&page=547, and I'm sure there are more I've yet to see. Everyone that I've seen enjoyed the coverage done by MLG and GotFrag, so I find it quite absurd that you're quite literally attacking the organization over it; perhaps GotFrag should pay journalists to write articles bashing your column for seemingly being written in 15 minutes at 4am, hoping of sparking up some attention by being as blindly negative as possible.
Perhaps you could pull your head out of MLG's ass for just 5 minutes to see that it can be done so much better. PC esports deserves more, but sadly GotForums hasn't been able to provide that ever since became part of MLG. If you can't see that then you're wildly delusional. GF used to be the best esports site by a mile but those days are long, LONG gone.
And please, son, if you think i need to bash GF just to get attention, you're just embarrassing yourself with a complete lack of knowledge. Incidentally, you call me "blindly negative" yet you're only picking up on my criticism of GF. You don't seem to notice the fact that the games - you know, what esports is actually about - were fantastic, as i said in the column itself.
The stream was A+, Vhell and Kintt did an amazing job, the production level was extremely high, and the quality is great. I can't take that away from those guys they did amazing. Now, they just need to work on their off-camera, off-stream quality and the events will be extremely successful.
I'm not on MLG's side in the grand scheme of things by any means, I hate them for being so successful by bringing in thousands of 12 year old Halo kiddies that only got to attend the event because their parents were happy they got straight A's in school. I hate that MLG took North America's best CS coverage website and got rid of their entire budget and completely ruining it without warning and leaving us with no real replacement. I don't think GotFrag is the best eSports site, nor even in the running for it, and they never will be again.
However, that's not what your article says and despite everything I've written above, I'm very grateful to MLG for a weekend full of entertainment and fun that they provided with their tournament and coverage. I don't care if their scores weren't updated and neither did the thousands of others that tuned in, so if you're so concerned with it, thne why don't you take it upon yourself to handle that? I'm just going to leave it at that because I never intended to try and convince you of how wrong you are, that's obviously impossible, I just felt that someone should point out the "flaws" in your claims for others.
"Your opinion is different from mine, therefore you are an idiot."
When you have something original to say you can try again. Until then, keep mindlessly flaming me and SK - oh sorry, should that be "biting your tongue?" You're doing exactly the same thing that you criticise me for and you throw the word "journalism" around like you have an concept of it whatsoever. When you've studied it for two years and sports journalism for one year, come back and try again. Or better yet: don't.
The best part is that you effectively agree with me on the whole but somehow your standards of what makes a good tournament just seem a lot lower. Oh, and the Simon Cowell thing was cute, but i would gladly have him shot if the opportunity ever arose.
The scores were updated at an ATROCIOUS pace and I will end my criticism there. That is the most fundamental thing one must do for coverage and it is was a joke. There is a serious void in coverage for MLG and GotFrag was supposed to provide that. MLG does a great job on their streams but please don't conflate GotFrag with the streams. GotFrag TV is long gone and if you ask Marc Turner he works for MLG and has nothing to do with GotFrag anymore. That is someone else's job. I am not sure what happened this weekend but I do agree with Zech's it was an embarrassment what GotFrag did or did not do I should say.
I mean really, somehow that led to "GotFrag should pay journalists" - well doesn't SK/coL/Loaded pay journalists? If GotFrag doesn't have the budget to cover what you think should be covered, then step up to the plate? Based on my experience with attending MLG events, you could've approached Ryan Moore directly and asked him for schedule/score updates and had no problems. The MLG PR people are always very accommodating when we've attended with cameras to do interviews. In fact, even sitting from home I received enough updates from our team captain and manager that I was never confused about when we would play or any results from other teams, so what's holding everyone else back?
The one thing you are right about is yes people like coL will absolutely HAVE to start covering the results so people can at least get those SOMEWHERE in case you missed a match or two because you had to walk away from your computer. So that is right other people will have to cover it since it seems there is a lack of budget or ability to do it at GotFrag but the rest of your argument and the whole premise is just ludicrous.
Also if GotFrag does not have the budget to cover MLG they should shut it down.
rmp mirrors arent that difficult... mage tries to fake cs + sometimes poly for swd and tries to get fingers procs to df -> poly priest then unload damage on rogue in danger situation (kidney) cc rogue / or enemy mage
priest stays at pillar tries to dispell buffs from rogue and from partners position to not get polyed, sometimes fear / or help nuking -> heal swd polys ... if hes focused he tries to survive until enemy rogue has no cooldowns to stay on him...
rogue does the rogue battle, either sticking to priest -> tunnelvision, or go on rogue and go defensive / offensive at the right time, (your own priest in cc / enemy priest in cc) you dont have to coordinate much... there are jsut little things like if you counterspell an incoming poly -> priest swds at the same time -> wasted swd can be polyed but for this he has the pillar... and coordinate the nuke... even an unpracticed rmp of for example pookz kalimist and phenomenon would farm loaded in mirrors, when they play together for the first time... undoubtly anyone agress that BB was better than SK.US single skill wise (apart from pookz) and they still lost the mirror, its just not every rmp that is sick is that good in mirrors...
for example we played sk eu and had like 25% win against them, where dignitas had 50% but we still went 50%+ in mirrors versus dignitas... that doesnt make us the better team.. the better team is the one that does well against counters... loaded is the only rmp beating col.blacks beastcleave at all, the other rmps are like lvl 1 characters when they face them, not one round win at IEM
Would be more interesting tbh:)
The thing about this was that coL hadn't practiced RMP in a very long time since they got their 4 man roster. They haven't practiced it with the season 8 gear and the commentators said that. Therefore they were a bit surprised that they were going to try their luck mirroring against the "world's best RMP." I guess when you know a team hasn't practiced RMP and they come out using it, it was surprising but not really a "secret weapon" so to speak (can't have it a secret weapon when you don't practice that comp ;D)
Sad that the blizzard rules still dont allow to open offline servers.
Awesome tournament and I'm happy for BB they deserved it and hats off to them with the practice possibilites they have coming here and winning it just shows how good they are! BB numberone =)
Oh must not forget the stream was awesome, commentating really insightful and proffesional I hope to see another MLG soon :)
I'm just giving my perspective as a non-hardcore fan.